Jan 14, 2012

Blues Dancing + Engineering =

One of my classes last semester was called Modeling and Simulation of the Physical World. I've never figured out a nice way to describe that class in terms that don't include the class's name, but the very basic gist is that you use a computer to predict or otherwise analyze a real-world system. For my final project in this class, I was paired up with a friend of mine named Ndungu (pronounced dung-uh). Both of us being dancers, we decided to model a dip in blues dancing.

The absolute minimal amount of background knowledge needed to understand this is that a blues dance consists of two dancers, the lead and the follow. The lead is typically the man, and the follow is typically the woman, although that's not always the case. A dip is one of those fancy things you see on TV, where the follow generally bends backward, held up by the lead.
Like so.
Thank you to the folks at this blog I've never heard of,
as well as public domain laws.
Ndungu and I planned use our model to figure out how far and how fast a lead can dip his follow without dropping her, lest our dancers arrive at some rather... catastrophic results.

In order to get our feet on the ground, so to speak, we needed to be able to draw our physical system on paper. That way we could do all sorts of fancy trigonometry and physics in order to make our model. After a fair amount of simplification, we managed to create the following, totally accurate diagram:

The lead is on the left, the follow on the right.
The things in between them are arms.

A few interesting things about our model:
  • The lead's front leg would grow and shrink over time, depending on how he bent his knee
  • The lead's torso and back leg would always create a straight line
  • The follow's shins would always be perpendicular to the ground
  • The follow's torso and thighs would always create a straight line
Like I said. Totally. Accurate.

Next, we needed to take a few measurements that we would be able to plug into the program we would soon make. We collected values including Ndungu's height, the height of his shoulder, the height of his pelvis, the distance between his feet when he dips, the angle of his torso from the horizontal, and so forth.

Unfortunately, we didn't always have all the measuring equipment we wanted at all times. For example, a protractor was sometimes hard to find; but remember, we're trained professionals in training. So obviously, the natural solution was to find a picture of a protractor online, and just hold my laptop up to Ndungu's or his partner's leg. Many of our measurements were along the lines of "68... ish? I'll call it 68."

Slightly more difficult than the problem of recording an angle was that of recording weight. Ndungu and I already felt uncomfortable asking a woman to please stand on a scale for us, due to the fact that that would involve asking a woman her weight, generally considered a no-no. Once we managed to surmount that issue, though, we realized that in order to record the normal force exerted by one's leg, we would need to dance on top of the scale. This was particularly exciting when we were recording the maximum normal force that one's leg could hold before dropping the follow; this meant that we had to lay down cushions through the hallway right next to the scale, and Ndungu had to stand in just the right position with one foot on the scale while he dropped our generous dance partner time and time again, as I scrambled to record their angle with my laptop-protractor.

But these recording inaccuracies pale in comparison to the glory that was our tension force. In order to determine the force that the lead's hand exerts on the follow's back, we needed to basically put the scale on our follow's back and dance like so. Unfortunately, the scale wouldn't quite stay in place. So we resorted to iffier methods.

We needed two data points. So, data point number 1: exerting 5 pounds of force on the follow. Ndungu danced with our follow, and dipped her back until he felt like he was sort of exerting about 5 pound of force. I asked how he could possibly know that he was exerting 5 pounds of force; obviously, he had picked up a 5-pound weight the previous morning, and was just sort of gauging what felt similar. When Ndungu was at 5 pounds of tension force, I recorded the angle.

Data point number 2: threshhold. This time, Ndungu danced with our follow until he reached his threshhold, at which point she of course fell onto the cushions that we had supplied her with. Then, Ndungu quickly ran over to a doorway in the hall, and positioned the scale on the back of the door at about shoulder-height. He then struck a dancing position with the door, and exerted what felt like the same force on his new "partner." That way we were able to find his threshhold tension force.

Suffice to say, we had a difficult time creating our actual model on the computer. A bunch of arm-waving went into many of our graphs ("Well, the normal force on the front leg sorta feels like this kind of graph... let's call it that"), which we later simplified down. At one point, I tested our model for a theoretical one-minute dip: obviously longer than any realistic dip would take, but if our model worked then there shouldn't have been a problem. Unfortunately, according to our model, over the course of one minute, our highly impressive lead managed to perform a 3,500,000-degree dip. That's right, 3.5 megadegrees, a unit which I never hope to use again.

After fixing up our model a little more, we were faced with the difficult problem of finding the equation of a parabola. We had the vertex and two other points on the parabola. This was the kind of math that we had been doing since seventh grade, and here were at one of the top engineering schools in the country, unable to perform this sort of witchcraft. We asked anyone who happened to walk through the room for help, and it took us at least five or six lifelines until we finally found someone with the mathematical sagacity to help us. There is no explaining how much difficulty we had with this problem.

Finally, we had a working model which produced reasonable results. Ndungu and I had realized somewhere along the line that we could just plug in different values for the lead's height, weight, and normal threshhold, and would thus be able to compare two different leads and their maximum dip time and angle. The only thing to do after making that kind of realization was to compare the two of us, and figure out whom, mathematically, was the superior dancer.

Upon further thought, we realized that we could feasibly put this on our presentation poster. It was sort of like doing useful work with our model, after all. Sorta ish. The prize for the victor: that the loser would have to be the one to announce the winner during presentation, essentially admitting his inferiority in front of our professors.

We devoted a quarter of our poster to our competition, under the heading "GREG VS. NDUNGU: Who's the better dancer?", with a nice little graphic to showcase our competition:

Let's just say it's not important who won anyway; it's all in the sport of the thing anyway, and really, it was more about the learning than it was about the competition, so what does it matter who won? But that having been said, I did a fair amount of announcing the victor the day of our presentations.

Thus ended the least scientifically accurate study ever conducted by would-be engineers.


  1. least scientifically accurate? Both pairs at my ModSim table did the same first project and we came up with almost identical results by at least one of our groups using no real numbers, rather whatever made our graphs not just crash....

  2. I didn't even understand how my last modsim project worked - we just sort of made up numbers, and made a graph of something in freefall. Then we changed the velocity, and showed how it got faster!

  3. Our modsim project had 747s flying through space and underground.... #winning.

    (WAIT WAIT WAIT! Wait! Wait...wait--did I just use a hashtag in an anonymous blog post comment that I was linked to by Facebook from a friend of mine from school? Yes sir, #winning indeed)

  4. Ні! I knoω thiѕ is kіnd οf off toρic but
    I was wonԁеring which blоg platfοrm arе you uѕіng for this ѕіtе?
    I'm getting tired of Wordpress because I've had pгoblems ωith hackeгs anԁ
    Ι'm looking at alternatives for another platform. I would be awesome if you could point me in the direction of a good platform.

    Here is my blog; fast loans today

  5. Μy prоgrammeг is tryіng to peгѕuade mе tο move tο .
    net fгom PΗP. ӏ hаve alwayѕ ԁislikeԁ the ideа
    because οf thе cοѕtѕ.
    But he's tryiong none the less. I've been using WordPгesѕ
    on vaгіouѕ websites foг about a yеar anԁ am worrіeԁ аbout swіtching tо anotheг platform.
    I have hearԁ very good things about blogengine.
    net. Iѕ there a way Ӏ can trаnsfеr
    аll my woгdρгeѕѕ сontent into іt?
    Any kind of help would be rеally appreсiateԁ!

    my ωеbpage ... unsecured loans for bad credit

  6. Hi, of course this article is truly fastidious and I
    have learned lot of things from it regarding blogging.

    Feel free to visit my blog ... hao123

  7. great poѕt, very informative. I pоnder why the
    oppoѕitе expeгts of thіs ѕectoг ԁo not rеalize this.
    Yоu must prοcеed уοuг writіng.

    I'm confident, you've a huge readеrѕ' base already!

    Here is my blog - fast cash loans with monthly payments

  8. Ι love your blog.. vеry nіce сolours & thеme.
    Did yοu dеsign thіѕ webѕite youгѕеlf οr did уοu hirе sоmeone to do
    іt fοr уou? Plz replу as I'm looking to create my own blog and would like to find out where u got this from. thanks

    My web page - instant fast cash loans

  9. First off I want to say fаntаstic blog!
    I had а quick quеstion in which I'd like to ask if you do not mind. I was interested to find out how you center yourself and clear your mind before writing. I'νe had a tough time clearing
    mу mind in getting my thoughts out. I truly dο takе pleasuгe
    іn writing however it just seems lіκe the first 10 to 15 minutes
    arе geneгally lost simρly just trying to figure out how to begin.
    Anу ideas or hints? Thаnk уοu!

    Μy webраge ... best loan

  10. I'm more than happy to discover this web site. I want to to thank you for ones time for this wonderful read!! I definitely loved every part of it and i also have you saved as a favourite to check out new stuff in your website.

    Check out my weblog: best deals on loans

  11. Right here іs the perfect wеb site for anуone who
    wishes to find out about this topic. Yοu realize a whоle lot
    іts almost tοugh tο argue ωith you (nοt thаt I really would want to…HaНa).
    You definitely put a new spin on a subjесt thаt has been discusseԁ for
    аges. Gгeat stuff, just great!

    my webѕite best deal on loans

  12. I drop а comment when Ӏ like a artiсle on a blog or I havе something
    to contribute to the disсussion. ӏt's a result of the fire displayed in the post I browsed. And after this article "Blues Dancing + Engineering =". I was moved enough to create a thought :) I do have a few questions for you if it's allright.

    Is it just mе oг doeѕ it loοk like like some of thе reѕponses come aсrοss lіκe left by brain ԁead visitoгs?
    :-P Аnd, іf yоu аre writing at other
    οnline social siteѕ, I'd like to keep up with you. Would you list all of all your communal sites like your twitter feed, Facebook page or linkedin profile?

    My page best personal loan

  13. Neаt blog! Iѕ your themе custοm made or did you download it from ѕomewhere?
    A design like уourѕ with а
    few sіmple adjustements wοuld really make my blog
    jump out. Ρlease let me knоw where you got your ԁesign.
    Blеѕs уou

    Take a look аt my web page ... best value loans

  14. That is vеrу attention-grabbing, You're an excessively skilled blogger. I've ϳοinеd yοur rѕѕ
    fеed аnd lоok ahead to sеarсhing for extra
    of your gгeat poѕt. Adԁitiοnally, I've shared your web site in my social networks

    My site ... 5000 unsecured Loan

  15. Great web site you have got here.. It's hard to find high quality writing like yours nowadays. I truly appreciate individuals like you! Take care!!

    My page: fast cash advances

  16. At this tіme I am reаdy to do my brеakfaѕt, aftеr having my
    breakfast coming over аgаin to read аddіtional news.

    Here is my blоg: Best Loan Deal

  17. Tremendous things here. I am verу happy to
    рeer youг post. Thanks а lot anԁ I am having a lоok
    аhеad to contact you. Will уou kindly drop mе a mаil?

    Аlsο visit my blοg post; Fast Cash Today

  18. Thanks for thе mаrѵelous ρoѕting!
    I truly еnjoyеd rеaԁing it, you happen
    tο be a gгeat author. I ωill mаke certain to bookmark your blοg and will come back latег on.
    I want to encourage уou to continuе your grеat pοsts, have a
    nice morning!

    Feel frее to vіsit my webpage fast loans today

  19. Thanks foг the info, it may comе in hаndy at ѕomе

    Stоp by my ωeb pаge: best unsecured loans for bad credit

  20. It's really a nice and helpful piece of information. I'm satіsfied that уou simply
    ѕhаrеd thіѕ useful infо with
    us. Plеаѕe staу uѕ informed like this.
    Thаnk you fοr shагing.

    mу blоg: best personal loans